Welcome to Hall or No Hall

The site is simple—two writers debate whether a MLB, NFL or NBA player belongs in their respective sport's Hall of Fame. Each week we select a player and the two writers independently draft their own opinions. Sometimes the writers will arrive at the same conclusion using frighteningly similar arguments. Sometimes they’ll differ so dramatically you’ll think they are talking about different players. Either way, we hope you enjoy the site.

Johnny Damon

August 17, 2011

A 17-year veteran, Johnny Damon has had a long and fruitful baseball career. Most likely his numbers and accolades will shock you, as much as a man that looks like Jesus should. After starting his career in Kansas City, and a short stint with the A's, Damon found himself as an iconic piece of the 2004 Boston Red Sox World Series Championship team. He won another ring with the rival Yankees (yay free agency!), and since has bounced around to Detroit and Tampa Bay. Approaching the sacred 3,000 hit mark, Hallornohall.com offers insight to Caveman's possibility of having a bronze Jesus to call his own.

Career Statistics (through mid-2011)
G AB R H 2B 3B HR RBI SB BA OBP SLG OPS
2388 9394 1623 2688 507 105 225 1098 396 .286 .353 .434 .788
Awards
  • 2 All-Star Selections (2002, 2005)

Continue reading to see what we have to say...